Math check?
TI's 12 points in round 2 (4 CORV's x 3 CP each) + 10 points in round 3 (2 DREAD's x 5 CP each) is correct, but only 2 points in the last round after taking out Midnight Four (4 Night Warriors x 2 CP each--see discussion with GM about Midnight Four) and Rancors 2 and 10 (2 rancors x 2 CP each) seems off. Wouldn't that be 12 + 10 + 8 + 4 = 34?
TNO's 19 points in round 2 come from ISD Conquest 6 + 13 units in hangar = 19, which is correct. But then in round 3, TNO received only 4 points, but it looks like TNO should have (1 rancor x 2 CP) + Midnight One (4 Night Warriors x 2 CP each) = 2 + 8 = 10. Then TNO received only 2 points in round 4 despite taking out Midnight 5 (4 Night Warriors x 2 CP each = 8)?
Total should be 19 + 10 + 8 = 37. Maybe it should really be 5 Night Warriors (Midnight One + 1 other Night Warrior) since the damage came to 43.2 (43.2 / 8 health per nightwarrior = 5.4, so 5 killed?), except Eidolon didn't specify from which group, so I'm not sure whether to take away one Night Warrior kill from TI or from TS. Anyway, total TNO score would be either 37 or else 37 + 2 = 39? Unless you want to give him additional points for the TNO AT-ST's he killed with the Rancors at the end of round 3, which I thought was awesome.
TS's 18 from round 3 is correct. (1 CORV x 3 CP) + Thug Riders (5 x 1 each) + Thug Rollers (5 x 1 each) + Red Skulls (5 x 1 each) = 18. But 20 for round 4 seems incorrect? In round four it looks like TS should have had (6 Rancors x 2 CP each) + Midnight Two (4 Night Warriors x 2 CP each) + Midnight Three (4 Night Warriors x 2 CP each) + Rancor 9 (2 CP) = 12 + 8 + 8 + 2 = 30, bringing TS's total to 18 from round 3 + 30 from round 4 = 48 total?
If those calculations are right, that would mean TS with 48 (or 46 if we we took Eidolon's 5th Night Warrior from Hale), TNO with 37 (or 39 including a 5th Night Warrior), and TI with 34 (or 32 if we took the 5th Night Warrior from me).
The order of the prizes wouldn't change (Gold - Hale; Silver - Eidlon; Bronze - Severus; Aluminum - Hoppus), but the cash payouts would.
Or is my math way off?
UPDATE: I included onboard units in TNO's calculation but not in TI's and TS's. Each of the four CORV's TI destroyed deployed 1 INF and 1 GAV only, leaving 1 INF still on board. That's 4 additional points, which if counted would bring TI's total to 34 + 4 = 38 (or 36 if you took the 5th Night Warrior from me instead of Hale). Except I see one of Hale's later comments about a "slight error with the number of onboard units deployed from the CORV's." If you were referring to the four CORV's not deploying the last INF and the Ruby Dawn not deploying any, I don't believe that was in error. It costs 1 AP per deployment, and the CORV's were out of AP.
I think we need a GM ruling here on a) whether Eidolon gets that 5th Night Warrior and if so whether that means taking one away from TS or TI or just waving the magic wand and saying there was an extra one by herself out there, and b) whether onboard units that did not deploy due to AP limits (1 INF each in the case of the four CORV's for TI, and 2 INFs + 1 GAV in the case of the Ruby Dawn for TS) should be added to the calculation for TI and TS (and just assume Thug Riders + Thug Rollers + Red Skulls were reinforced by existing ground forces so no recalculation of ground combat is necessary) or not.
If I can make a suggestion: First, the deployment ruling was left unchallenged at the time and we continued to the next round assuming all units deployed, so I would say not to include the onboard units for the CORV's (even though that means TI takes bronze instead of the silver I think it would have taken with the 4 onboard units). Second, TNO only specified Midnight One, so I would count the additional DMG as overkill and TNO only receives credit for the four Night Warriors, not five. Then final scores would be: TS = 48 for the gold, TNO 37 for the silver, TI 34 for the bronze, and WS 10 for the aluminum.
