The right to bare arms isn't about hunting, it is about the right of the people to defend themselves against an overbearing and out-of-control government if necessary, you know, the way they did against the King. Never forget, this nation is a Union of States, a representative Republic, and that the States are not to ever be shackled completely to the Federal Government.
Oh I don't hunt. I just shoot. If you work it out economically it's cheaper to buy your food at a grocery store anyways. Hunting license, cleaning, etc.
And that term "completely" you use in referencing Federal Power over States is interesting. I wonder what it could be expanded upon to mean? That the Fed Govt can trump State law in "extreme common good" instances, extreme, common, and good all being defined by Federal standards of course?
I partially agree with you that State law should precede Federal. But there's just a lot of problems with that as well. Inevitably, you'd end up with total polarization from state to state, even more so than now I mean. In the long run, you'd have states warring with each other because of the steep divides that State dominance would create.
I disagree that a Representative Republic is the FAIREST way to run a democracy, although Direct Democracy is logistically unmanageable (though those same problems enter Representative Elections as well).
The Constitution. . it had some good ideas, but we like to think we invented this whole revolution/democracy thing. Consider the ethical contradictions between the specific language of the document and it's authors, and regarding the 2nd Amendment itself further consider the difference in the world of 1791 and today. The forefathers could never have imagined the country the USA is today from it's humbled beginnings back then. I hesitate to say it for fear of being misconstrued as espousing the ideals myself but from an extreme perspective, do you think they would have written the 2nd Amendment in the terminology it was written in now if the slaves were already freed? They didn't consider that. Do you think if the 2nd Amendment were never passed, that it would ever get passed today? Even in a 100% Congress/Senate of EITHER Party? The current state of America? no way.
I'm not willing to give up my guns either, but I'm not going to lie to myself and be under any illusions about the whole issue either. That's like honestly believing we are a just upright country because we say so. I don't know, no matter how you slice it, Manifest Destiny seems like some bullshit from the
Indian Native American (whatever we decided they are to be called for time being!) perspective. I guess since they'd have never built NYC or huge corporatations or Wine Country or more importantly and dear to my heart the Blue Moon brewery we did the right thing though. That being said, I'm super happy to be here
I'm just not going to kid myself that everything I/We have isn't at someone elses expense. C'est la vie!
BESIDES, we should all really be directing our Contempt at that dirty Expatriate Greg! You should have just moved to Texas if you liked the Chilean Flag that much!